Artificial intelligence can write an email, answer a question, and generate an image in seconds. But what happens when people begin to rely on it for work, thought, and creativity? In this best-of episode of In the Market with Janet Parshall, Janet and guest Doug Smith discuss those questions through the lens of Christian discipleship.
Smith spent decades in software engineering and writes about how technology shapes human behavior. His book Unintelligence: The Lies Behind Today’s AI and the Truth You Need to Thrive argues that Christians should look beyond what AI can produce and ask what using it may do to them. Janet agrees that technology cannot be placed in a separate part of a believer’s life. Their conversation focuses on Smith’s story, his concerns about dependence on AI, and his claim that a machine can imitate intelligence without possessing it.
Janet and Smith begin with a practical question: how should Christians approach a tool that is becoming common at work and at home? Smith draws on his software career, his research into screen habits, and his Christian faith to explain why he wants people to think carefully before handing tasks to generative AI. The discussion also explores a much older debate about whether machines can truly think.
Janet opens by saying that AI is no longer a future issue. It is already part of ordinary life, and she believes Christians need to think about it both critically and biblically. She is especially concerned that people may treat it as a neutral tool without asking how it might shape their habits or understanding of themselves.
For Janet, following Christ includes decisions made at a computer screen. She points to Galatians 2:20, where Paul speaks of being crucified with Christ and living by faith in him. Janet applies that conviction to technology use:
You can't compartmentalize your faith.
That is why she welcomes Smith’s work. She describes him as someone who understands software from the inside but also wants to help the church ask deeper questions. What do the people building these tools believe about human beings? What are they trying to make their products do? And what might Christians give up if they turn to a chatbot whenever a task becomes hard?
Janet calls listeners to be discerning rather than simply attracted to a new tool because it is fast or impressive. She and Smith do not try to cover every issue raised by AI in this interview. Instead, they spend much of the conversation on a starting question: what is intelligence, and can a machine have it?
Smith says his interest in technology began early. He studied electronics engineering, learned computers and software engineering, and built a career in the field. He also enjoyed science fiction and learning how things work. Those interests later met a growing concern about the way large technology companies design products.
Before writing about AI, Smith researched why screens hold people’s attention. He noticed familiar scenes, such as families sitting together in a restaurant while each person looked at a device. His research led him into behavioral psychology, neuroscience, technology, and theology. In his earlier book, Unintentional, he argued that software can be designed to shape users’ desires and habits.
Smith brought that concern to generative AI when tools such as ChatGPT became widely available. He began writing articles about possible uses of AI, including research and creative work. He also watched his own profession adopt it. At the software company where he had worked for seven years, AI use was initially optional. When the company later required it for software engineering, Smith says he had to decide whether his convictions would change how he worked.
He chose to leave a company he says he loved. He had expected to stay for years more and needed the income, so he does not describe the choice as easy. He says he wrote out 12 reasons for his decision, including his concern that using AI to perform skilled work would weaken abilities he had spent years developing. He also feared becoming dependent on a technology he did not trust.
Janet pauses over the personal cost of that decision and asks listeners to pray for Smith’s household. Smith says leaving the job also gave him time to finish Unintelligence sooner than he otherwise could have. He presents the book as work done from a sense of calling, not simply an interest in writing about a popular subject. Janet points listeners to Smith’s website, where he says he has written further about his reasons for not using big-tech generative AI in software engineering.
Smith uses the phrase intentionality imbalance to describe a difference between technology companies and many of their users. In his view, companies put enormous effort into learning what keeps people engaged, while users often open an app without much thought about what it is designed to do. His goal in Unintentional was to help readers become more intentional about screen use.
In Unintelligence, he applies a similar idea to thinking. Smith argues that when people repeatedly hand tasks to generative AI, they may lose practice in doing those tasks themselves. He calls this an “intelligence exchange”: people are encouraged to rely on a machine described as intelligent while giving less attention to their own God-given abilities.
Smith links that concern to everyday pressures. People are busy and tired, he acknowledges, and AI is often offered as an easy way to get something done. But he believes that convenience can make it less likely that they will stop to ask what a tool is doing to their skills or judgment. Janet presses him on why Christians should spend time on questions that may seem abstract, such as what it means to be human and made in God’s image.
His answer is that those questions will be answered for people if they do not consider them for themselves. Smith says technology companies may describe human limitations and machine abilities in ways that do not reflect a biblical view of humanity. He wants Christians to make room for serious thought, even when daily life is full. Janet shares that concern and says believers should not plead ignorance about choices they are making with AI.
To explain why he disputes claims about machine intelligence, Smith turns to the history of computing. He discusses Alan Turing, whose work helped break coded Nazi messages during World War II. Turing later proposed a test often called the imitation game or the Turing test. As Smith explains it, a machine passes when a person communicating with it cannot tell that it is a machine rather than another person.
Smith does not deny that today’s chatbots can be convincing. He says their conversational form is part of why they can be so persuasive. People are used to exchanging written messages with friends, family, and coworkers. When a chatbot responds in the same format, it may feel as if a person is answering.
But Smith challenges what the test is taken to show. If a machine fools a person, he argues, that establishes that its imitation worked. It does not establish that the machine understands its words. Janet raises the same concern when she describes a machine generating an image of a cat. The result may look new to the user, but the speakers distinguish that process from a person’s creative thought.
Smith explains his working definition of intelligence as the ability to choose for a purpose. In his view, a person has awareness, meaning, and aims when making a choice. A machine runs code and algorithms, even when its output is complex and useful. He therefore rejects the claim that increasingly convincing outputs will turn a machine into a person or give it human intelligence.
Machines don't and never will have purposes.
Janet connects this point to the Christian belief that human beings are made in God’s image. She is troubled when language about AI seems to give machines human qualities. Smith agrees that Christians need to keep the difference in view, particularly when a chatbot’s responses make that difference easy to forget.
Smith also introduces Michael Polanyi, a Christian chemist and philosopher who was a contemporary of Turing. Smith says Polanyi challenged the idea that a machine’s convincing performance means it knows or thinks. He credits philosopher Esther Meek with helping him understand Polanyi’s work and explain it in his book.
One part of that challenge concerns meaning. When Janet and Smith speak to each other, Smith says, they choose words because they have something they mean to communicate. They draw on their knowledge of the world, the conversation, and their purposes. A machine can produce words that fit a pattern, he argues, but it does not know what those words mean.
Smith says the human element is also needed to interpret what a machine produces. He points back to Turing’s code-breaking work: a machine could process information, but people understood the significance of its output. For Smith, faster processing and more data do not remove that need for human understanding.
He applies the same distinction to creativity. Smith says people can have genuine ideas and moments of insight. They do not create from nothing, as God does, but he believes God has given them the ability to think and make meaningful work. Generative AI, by contrast, draws on training data and produces new combinations through algorithms. Janet says this is why she wants to read a writer who has wrestled with a subject, not merely text produced in imitation of one.
Near the end of the interview, Janet reads Polanyi’s warning, quoted in Smith’s book through Meek, about confusing a successful imitation with reality:
But a deception, however compelling, does not qualify thereby as truth.
Janet says the line is worth remembering. Smith hopes it will help readers hold to what they know about human beings even when AI seems remarkably human in conversation. He also tells Janet that no part of Unintelligence was written, edited, or inspired by AI; he credits God, his own work, and his human editors.
The interview ends before Janet and Smith finish the book’s first chapter. Janet says she wants to return to it in later conversations rather than rush through questions she considers important. Smith’s central request in this discussion is for people to consider not only what AI can do for them, but also how relying on it may change the way they think and work.
For Janet, that careful attention is part of honoring Christ in ordinary life. She encourages listeners to read, think, and bring their technology choices into the same walk of faith as everything else they do. This best-of episode and its audio preserve their extended conversation about work, intelligence, and what Smith believes makes human thought distinct.