What happens when someone’s words leave you doubting your own memory, judgment, and worth? On In the Market with Janet Parshall, Janet talks with Christian counselor Laurel Slade Wagner about narcissistic control and the harm it can cause within families. Their conversation centers on Wagner’s book, How to Respond to a Narcissist: A Christian’s Guide for Standing Up to Control, Manipulation, and Abuse.
Rather than staying with definitions alone, the episode turns to callers’ questions. Parents describe losing contact with children and grandchildren. Others wonder whether they have become the problem, how to protect their identity in a difficult relationship, or why someone who hurts them can seem kind to everyone else. Wagner offers practical guidance while returning often to prayer, truth, and support from other people.
Janet and Wagner discuss how narcissistic behavior may appear in private, why it can be hard to recognize, and how people affected by it can seek help without losing sight of their faith or identity.
Janet begins by asking Wagner to explain gaslighting. Wagner says the word is now used so widely that its serious meaning can get lost. In her counseling work, she uses it to describe a form of emotional and psychological abuse that can deeply shake a person’s confidence. Someone exposed to it repeatedly may begin to question not only what happened, but also whether they are reasonable, likable, or able to relate well to others.
Wagner describes several ways this can happen. A person may be called “crazy,” “too emotional,” or “too sensitive.” They may face constant criticism, or an insult hidden inside what first sounds like praise. Wagner recalls hearing a message from her father that began by calling her smart and ended by calling her an airhead. Such mixed messages, she says, leave a person unsure what to believe about themselves.
Janet stresses that this kind of harm may not be visible. There may be no outward injury, yet the person receiving the messages can feel as though they are losing their mind. Wagner says she has worked with people who became so unsure of themselves that they withdrew from others. Isolation can make the confusion worse, especially when the person causing harm seems charming and helpful in public.
That public and private difference matters in church life too, Wagner says. Someone may serve at church or hold a respected role while treating a spouse or child badly at home. Janet and Wagner want listeners to understand why a person describing this experience may be deeply hurt even when others have seen only the agreeable side of the relationship.
Wagner also sees these problems amid growing social disconnection and self-focus. When Janet asks why narcissism seems to be discussed so often, Wagner points to several possible factors, including better recognition of the behavior as well as the effects she sees from social media and technology.
Several callers bring the conversation from general patterns into painful family situations. Pam in Florida says she has lost contact with her son and two grandchildren after conflict involving her daughter-in-law. She cannot call or visit them and has been unable to see her grandchildren for about two years. Wagner acknowledges how painful that loss is and says she hears from many parents and grandparents in similar circumstances.
Wagner suggests that Pam’s son may feel pressure to avoid conflict at home. She advises Pam not to speak badly of his wife if she does get a chance to talk with him. Instead, she encourages small, steady efforts to show him who she is and that she remains available. Wagner also suggests looking for an appropriate way to reconnect with the grandchildren when they are older.
Prayer is central to Wagner’s response. She encourages Pam to pray for each family member by name and to ask God to preserve their memories of good times together.
And so she might have control over whether or not you can see them physically, but she cannot stop you from connecting with them through prayer.
Janet echoes that encouragement. Even when a grandparent cannot share ordinary moments with a child, she says, no other person can prevent that grandparent from bringing the child before God in prayer. Wagner also urges estranged family members to stay close to people who know and love them rather than withdrawing into shame.
Another caller, Valerie, asks whether there is hope after her daughter has cut off people close to her. Wagner does not promise a quick change. She speaks plainly about how hard waiting can be, especially during holidays, and encourages Valerie to place her hope in the Lord. She also recommends connecting with other hurting parents and grandparents, including through support groups, so the waiting is not carried alone.
For families who still have some contact but struggle to arrange holiday visits, Wagner suggests flexibility. Her own blended family sometimes gathers on a different day so more adult children and grandchildren can attend. For someone who cannot see family at all, she recommends spending time with people who care for them and finding ways to show kindness to others. The holiday’s meaning, she says, is not limited to one gathering on one date.
Two callers ask a question that troubles them personally: What if they are the narcissist? Don in Texas says his mother and wife have blamed him for problems in their relationships. Tom in Connecticut describes a long conflict with his sister, who has called him a narcissist. He tells Wagner that he wants to understand his own part in the conflict and take responsibility where he is wrong.
Wagner notices that both men are asking questions about themselves. She says the willingness to seek wisdom, consider another perspective, and change one’s behavior differs from the rigid pattern she associates with clinical narcissism. She points Don to Proverbs 18:2, which describes a fool who takes no pleasure in understanding but delights in expressing his own opinion.
Wagner describes the patterns she watches for over time: a lack of empathy, a strong sense of superiority, defensiveness, and an unwillingness to accept correction. She also mentions promises that are not kept, different behavior in public and private, and expecting more of others than of oneself. Her advice to Don is to learn what those patterns look like, then consider honestly whether they describe him. She encourages him to pray for God to reveal what needs to change.
With Tom, Wagner asks whether he can admit he might be wrong, feel compassion when someone is hurt, and learn new ways to respond. Based on what he shares, she says his desire to understand and take ownership does not sound like the clinical narcissism he fears. She is careful not to declare his sister a narcissist from the call. She does explain that reversing an accusation, saying in effect that the other person is the narcissist, can be one way a person avoids looking at their own conduct.
Janet asks how parents accused of being terrible parents can resist letting that accusation define their whole lives. Wagner advises them to remain connected to people who can reflect back what they know of their character. She also suggests remembering the ways they tried to bring their children to God while those children were growing up. For Wagner, truthful reflection and support from others help counter the despair that isolation can feed.
Teresa asks whether a family member’s narcissistic behavior could involve a demon. Wagner answers within the Christian framework she and Janet share, while saying she cannot know the spiritual condition of a particular person. She believes Satan is active in the world and that demonic involvement is possible, but she does not say that every narcissistic person has a demon.
Instead, Wagner explains that counselors look at behavior they can observe over time. She cites Luke 6:43–44, where Jesus speaks of recognizing a tree by its fruit. In this setting, she says, that means paying attention to lasting patterns such as exploitation, entitlement, and a lack of empathy rather than making a claim about a cause no one can see.
Wagner says a willing person can seek counseling and that some Christians also seek prayer through deliverance ministry. She cautions that, in her experience, people showing strong narcissistic patterns often resist counseling or attend to gain an ally against a spouse rather than to learn and change. Her answer keeps the focus on what a family can observe and what forms of help the person is willing to receive.
Another caller, Dawn, faces a different practical concern. She says her former husband has guardianship over their disabled adult son and has cut off her contact with him. Wagner urges her to seek legal counsel or an advocate for people with disabilities. The details of guardianship and visitation matter, she explains, and a lawyer can help Dawn understand what rights she has and what steps are available. In this case, Wagner does not offer a relationship tactic in place of legal guidance.
Leslie asks whether the spouse of a narcissist must change their personality to manage the relationship. Wagner says that changing who you are simply to keep the peace is not a healthy answer. If a close relationship requires someone to hide their temperament, strengths, or interests, she believes the problem needs to be addressed rather than accepted as that person’s duty.
You don't want to mold and conform to the image of who a narcissist wants you to be.
Wagner grounds that counsel in her belief that God created each person with care and purpose. She says a spouse should be able to grow and reflect who God made them to be, not become smaller to fit someone else’s demands. This is one reason her book focuses not only on recognizing manipulation but also on responding to it.
Alice, who grew up with a narcissistic parent, describes another part of the struggle. She has done trauma counseling but still falls into old habits and finds it hard to act with autonomy. Wagner urges her not to give up on finding a trauma recovery therapist who understands personality disorders. Healing from long-standing patterns, she says, may require exploring the beliefs beneath a person’s thoughts and choices, then setting small goals with support and accountability.
Wagner acknowledges Alice’s frustration without treating it as failure. She says healing can be a long process, with new areas becoming clear after earlier ones have been addressed. She recommends asking prospective counselors about their experience with trauma and personality disorders. The goal is to find someone equipped to walk with Alice through this stage of recovery, not to expect her to overcome it all at once.
Near the end of the hour, Reggie asks whether narcissistic behavior can come and go or differ by relationship. His father has been called a narcissist, yet Reggie has also seen him relate well to some people and has had good times with him himself. Wagner says that question captures part of what makes these relationships confusing.
In her experience, a person can be charming or kind when a relationship meets a desire for praise, control, or some other benefit. Conflict may become more visible when someone says no, challenges that person’s pride, or does not give them what they feel entitled to have. Wagner calls these desired benefits “narcissistic currencies.” She says the behavior may appear to ebb and flow, while a longer pattern remains.
Janet adds that the same parent may treat two children very differently, favoring one and dismissing another. That difference can make it harder for family members to agree on what they have experienced. For Wagner, looking at patterns across time and relationships is more useful than judging the situation by a few good or bad moments.
As the hour closes, Janet notes how many callers still have questions. She points listeners to Wagner’s books, her podcast Help! I Have a Narcissist in My Life, and the information accompanying the original episode. The calls have shown why Janet keeps returning to this subject: people are hurting and looking for a way forward.
Wagner’s answers do not promise that every relationship will be restored. They do offer listeners ways to respond to the circumstances described in the episode: pray for family members, stay connected to trustworthy people, seek skilled counseling or legal help when needed, and keep growing without surrendering the person God created them to be.